Tammy Alonso's Blog
Tammy Alonso's Blog
Left of Centre
send to a friend | print | comment
The Orie case and Tom Corbett
Last month’s preliminary hearing for state Senator Jane Orie (R-Allegheny) and her sister, Janine, answered one important question—they will stand trial on charges they used the senator’s taxpayer-funded legislative staff for campaign work.
But the evidence and witness testimony introduced raised a number of others.
First and foremost is why Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin has yet to be indicted. While a grand jury is currently probing her involvement, not only was it her campaign for the high court that is alleged to have benefited from the work done on taxpayer time, but an affidavit introduced into evidence during the hearing alleges that she and her senator sister tried to recruit a local labor consultant to deliver threats to Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen Zappala in an effort to stop the initial grand jury investigation into the senator.
Really? Threatening a public official? That also provides a whole new wrinkle in the likening of the Zappala-led investigation to a “Mafia hit” by Orie’s brother Jack, who at the time was serving as his sisters’ attorney. “Sending a message” via a labor consultant? Sounds awfully “Mafia-like” to me.
And, of course, predictably, Senator Orie’s new lawyer showed up at the hearing insisting that what she did wasn’t that bad, and besides, everyone does it. Didn’t these people learn anything from the Mike Veon trial? I guess not, since state Representative Bill DeWeese, facing the same kinds of charges, is trying to use the same kind of defense. And are they oblivious to the appearance of hypocrisy at best, desperation at worst, in attempting to enlist the same excuses that were so derisively laughed off and dismissed by many of those representing their side of the aisle when they were made by others?
But the biggest question coming out of all of this? How in the world did Attorney General Tom Corbett’s office miss this? In his nearly three-year-long “mission” to “clean up” Harrisburg, he’s gone after some of the biggest fish in the Capitol. It doesn’t get much bigger than the woman who, at the time of her indictment, was the senate majority whip, the No. 3 Republican in the chamber.
Add to that the fact that Jennifer Knapp Rioja, the intern whose complaint started the investigation, insists that the first call she made was not to the Allegheny County District Attorney’s office but rather to the state Attorney General’s office, which told her to contact local authorities. Not to mention the fact that staffers from the Orie office swore under oath at the hearing that they’ve been directed by the senator herself to perform campaign work on behalf of herself and her sister for the last nine years! And that the Orie office in question is right down the road from the one where some of the now-infamous Veon shenanigans took place.
The Attorney General’s office didn’t have to look very long or hard to find this one.
So the question remains, why didn’t they?
August 5, 2010 at 8:11 am













bill healy
Aug 5th, 2010
Maybe Tom Corbitt thinks the State Constitution only calls for him to operate his office in a partisan manner? Or maybe he’s just a rank political whore.
Signor Ferrarii
Aug 5th, 2010
While you raise excellent points, you are mistaken that Corbett has “gone after some of the biggest fish in the Capitol.”. His original round of indictments included only a single sitting legislator, a a sophomore rank-and-filer who just happened to be running in a competitive Senate race. When pulic pressure forced him to turn his sights on Republicans, Corbett again chose to indict a single rank-and-file member. DeWeese, the only member of leadership to be charged, was targeted on lesser charges only after published reports revealed the extent of the evidence against him, yet he remains uncharged in the caucus-wide activities at the the center of “Bonusgate.”
Pachanga
Aug 5th, 2010
Why should it surprise anyone that he turned a blind eye when his office initially received a complaint about Orie? She is a political ally. Look at the favor he did for his political ally and his republican representative in Bedford County. Bedford County District ATtorney was accused of rape and Corbett said it comes down to her word against his and that is not enough for a rape case to go forward. Most rape caes are he said/she said and here Higgins even admitted the sex act and offered a county commissioner a favor to keep everything quiet. But Corbett said everything was okay. Wasn’t the attorney for the Bill Higgins the Bedford District Attorney accused of raping a woman, Attorney Gleason from Johnstown whose firm and family are high officials in the Pa Republican Party? Sounds like the perfect attorney to talk Corbett into not doing a full and objective rape investigation in return for possible political favors? But then again, it was just a standing District Attorney with multiple assault convictions already on his record, why take a claim that he raped a woman in his office seriously?
Anthracite Alum
Aug 5th, 2010
He could have looked no closer than the Orie brother who works for him in the AG office or looked at the nomination petitions she circulated for him using senate staffers.
I would use the McGruff crime dog metaphor but that reminds me of the child predator that worked for Orie in Senate and dressed up like furry animals. I bet the AG’s office has really thrown the book at him.
Yea right.
What a cesspool.
Curiouser
Aug 5th, 2010
Hold on a second. Not only does Jennifer Knapp Rioja “insist” that she called the AG first, her cellphone records show the order of the calls she made. This isn’t one woman’s word against someone else’s word. It’s a fact. She called OAG first. Period. End of story.
lee levan
Aug 5th, 2010
The problem here is that PA voters are not paying attention to the partisan prosecutorial hypocrisy of Corbett. Perhaps they are so used to political corruption that they are no longer sensitive to the seriousness of this particular corruption in public office.
And perhaps the mainsteam media is lying down on the job by not making this a running front page issue. Or maybe that is Onorato’s job and he’s not doing it vehemently enough. To be frank, the media likes nothing better than to sit back and let others do their job for them. Whatever happened to the good old days of investigative reporting and crusading journalists?
allegheny labor
Aug 17th, 2010
Why didn’t Corbett investigate and indict the Ories? Because their brother Jerry is on his staff in the Attorney General’s office. That, and plain old partisanship, gives the Ories immunity from prosecution by Tom Corbett.